Function to Return a JSON Like Objects Using VBA Collections and Arrays

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP





.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;







up vote
1
down vote

favorite












My goal is to create a compact function that can create a JSON Like object from JSON string. I want a function with a small footprint that I or anyone who wants to use it, can simply paste into a module and use. At 61 lines of code, I am happy with its size and portability.



Here is an image of JSON Object created from string data using a ScriptControl. Although the Locals Window displays the properties and values correctly, the object itself is extremely difficult to work with.



objJSON



This image shows an object created using getJSONCollection. Because it is made of VBA Collections and Arrays, it is very easy to work with.



colJSON



Option Explicit

Private Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Collection, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = New Collection
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)

If ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add results, "getArray"
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0

If TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If

col.Add Value, KeyNames(j)
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function

Sub TestJSONCollection()
Dim JSONExamples As Object, ExampleDoc As Object
Set ExampleDoc = getDocument("http://json.org/example.html")
Set JSONExamples = ExampleDoc.getElementsByTagName("Pre")
Example1 JSONExamples(0).innerText

End Sub

Sub Example1(JSONString As String)
Dim objJSON As Object, colJSON As Collection
Set objJSON = DecodeJSON(JSONString)
Set colJSON = getJSONCollection(JSONString)
Debug.Print "Example1: JSON String"
Debug.Print JSONString
Debug.Print String(20, "*") & "Example1: Output" & String(20, "*")

Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!title:", colJSON!glossary!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso!getArray()(0)
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1)(1), "Alt Syntax"
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee

End Sub

Function DecodeJSON(JSONString As String) As Object
With CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
.Language = "JScript"
Set DecodeJSON = .Eval("(" + JSONString + ")")
End With
End Function

Function getDocument(URL As String) As Object
Dim doc As Object
With CreateObject("MSXML2.XMLHTTP")
.Open "GET", URL, False
.send
If .readyState = 4 And .Status = 200 Then
Set doc = New MSHTML.HTMLDocument
doc.body.innerHTML = .responseText
Set getDocument = doc
Else
MsgBox "URL: " & vbCrLf & "Ready state: " & .readyState & vbCrLf & "HTTP request status: " & .Status, vbInformation, "URL Not Responding"
End If
End With
End Function


This creates a JSON Collection object from the first JSON example from json.org/example.html and outputs both the values and the method used to access the values to the Immediate Window.



Example1: JSON String




"glossary":
"title": "example glossary",
"GlossDiv":
"title": "S",
"GlossList":
"GlossEntry":
"ID": "SGML",
"SortAs": "SGML",
"GlossTerm": "Standard Generalized Markup Language",
"Acronym": "SGML",
"Abbrev": "ISO 8879:1986",
"GlossDef":
"para": "A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.",
"GlossSeeAlso": ["GML", "XML"]
,
"GlossSee": "markup"





********************Example1: Output********************
colJSON!glossary!title: example glossary
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title: S
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm: Standard Generalized Markup Language
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev: ISO 8879:1986
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para: A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0): GML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1): XML Alt Syntax
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee: markup


getJSONCollection:Function



Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Object, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)
If Len(Value) = 0 Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length - 1)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add "getArray", results
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0
'Extract Array from Dictionary
If TypeName(Value) = "Dictionary" Then
If Value.Exists("getArray") Then Value = Value("getArray")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If
col.Add KeyNames(j), Value
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function


Any feedback on ways to improve the performance or valid JSON strings that it can't parse would be appreciated?




Addendum



I modify the function to use Dictionaries instead of COllections to allow access to the keys.



Corrected the handling of the Javascript IsArray. It returns true when the value is vbNullString.







share|improve this question





















  • Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
    – Raystafarian
    Jun 14 at 21:43










  • Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
    – TinMan
    Jun 15 at 1:04
















up vote
1
down vote

favorite












My goal is to create a compact function that can create a JSON Like object from JSON string. I want a function with a small footprint that I or anyone who wants to use it, can simply paste into a module and use. At 61 lines of code, I am happy with its size and portability.



Here is an image of JSON Object created from string data using a ScriptControl. Although the Locals Window displays the properties and values correctly, the object itself is extremely difficult to work with.



objJSON



This image shows an object created using getJSONCollection. Because it is made of VBA Collections and Arrays, it is very easy to work with.



colJSON



Option Explicit

Private Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Collection, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = New Collection
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)

If ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add results, "getArray"
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0

If TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If

col.Add Value, KeyNames(j)
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function

Sub TestJSONCollection()
Dim JSONExamples As Object, ExampleDoc As Object
Set ExampleDoc = getDocument("http://json.org/example.html")
Set JSONExamples = ExampleDoc.getElementsByTagName("Pre")
Example1 JSONExamples(0).innerText

End Sub

Sub Example1(JSONString As String)
Dim objJSON As Object, colJSON As Collection
Set objJSON = DecodeJSON(JSONString)
Set colJSON = getJSONCollection(JSONString)
Debug.Print "Example1: JSON String"
Debug.Print JSONString
Debug.Print String(20, "*") & "Example1: Output" & String(20, "*")

Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!title:", colJSON!glossary!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso!getArray()(0)
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1)(1), "Alt Syntax"
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee

End Sub

Function DecodeJSON(JSONString As String) As Object
With CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
.Language = "JScript"
Set DecodeJSON = .Eval("(" + JSONString + ")")
End With
End Function

Function getDocument(URL As String) As Object
Dim doc As Object
With CreateObject("MSXML2.XMLHTTP")
.Open "GET", URL, False
.send
If .readyState = 4 And .Status = 200 Then
Set doc = New MSHTML.HTMLDocument
doc.body.innerHTML = .responseText
Set getDocument = doc
Else
MsgBox "URL: " & vbCrLf & "Ready state: " & .readyState & vbCrLf & "HTTP request status: " & .Status, vbInformation, "URL Not Responding"
End If
End With
End Function


This creates a JSON Collection object from the first JSON example from json.org/example.html and outputs both the values and the method used to access the values to the Immediate Window.



Example1: JSON String




"glossary":
"title": "example glossary",
"GlossDiv":
"title": "S",
"GlossList":
"GlossEntry":
"ID": "SGML",
"SortAs": "SGML",
"GlossTerm": "Standard Generalized Markup Language",
"Acronym": "SGML",
"Abbrev": "ISO 8879:1986",
"GlossDef":
"para": "A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.",
"GlossSeeAlso": ["GML", "XML"]
,
"GlossSee": "markup"





********************Example1: Output********************
colJSON!glossary!title: example glossary
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title: S
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm: Standard Generalized Markup Language
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev: ISO 8879:1986
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para: A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0): GML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1): XML Alt Syntax
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee: markup


getJSONCollection:Function



Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Object, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)
If Len(Value) = 0 Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length - 1)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add "getArray", results
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0
'Extract Array from Dictionary
If TypeName(Value) = "Dictionary" Then
If Value.Exists("getArray") Then Value = Value("getArray")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If
col.Add KeyNames(j), Value
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function


Any feedback on ways to improve the performance or valid JSON strings that it can't parse would be appreciated?




Addendum



I modify the function to use Dictionaries instead of COllections to allow access to the keys.



Corrected the handling of the Javascript IsArray. It returns true when the value is vbNullString.







share|improve this question





















  • Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
    – Raystafarian
    Jun 14 at 21:43










  • Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
    – TinMan
    Jun 15 at 1:04












up vote
1
down vote

favorite









up vote
1
down vote

favorite











My goal is to create a compact function that can create a JSON Like object from JSON string. I want a function with a small footprint that I or anyone who wants to use it, can simply paste into a module and use. At 61 lines of code, I am happy with its size and portability.



Here is an image of JSON Object created from string data using a ScriptControl. Although the Locals Window displays the properties and values correctly, the object itself is extremely difficult to work with.



objJSON



This image shows an object created using getJSONCollection. Because it is made of VBA Collections and Arrays, it is very easy to work with.



colJSON



Option Explicit

Private Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Collection, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = New Collection
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)

If ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add results, "getArray"
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0

If TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If

col.Add Value, KeyNames(j)
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function

Sub TestJSONCollection()
Dim JSONExamples As Object, ExampleDoc As Object
Set ExampleDoc = getDocument("http://json.org/example.html")
Set JSONExamples = ExampleDoc.getElementsByTagName("Pre")
Example1 JSONExamples(0).innerText

End Sub

Sub Example1(JSONString As String)
Dim objJSON As Object, colJSON As Collection
Set objJSON = DecodeJSON(JSONString)
Set colJSON = getJSONCollection(JSONString)
Debug.Print "Example1: JSON String"
Debug.Print JSONString
Debug.Print String(20, "*") & "Example1: Output" & String(20, "*")

Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!title:", colJSON!glossary!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso!getArray()(0)
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1)(1), "Alt Syntax"
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee

End Sub

Function DecodeJSON(JSONString As String) As Object
With CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
.Language = "JScript"
Set DecodeJSON = .Eval("(" + JSONString + ")")
End With
End Function

Function getDocument(URL As String) As Object
Dim doc As Object
With CreateObject("MSXML2.XMLHTTP")
.Open "GET", URL, False
.send
If .readyState = 4 And .Status = 200 Then
Set doc = New MSHTML.HTMLDocument
doc.body.innerHTML = .responseText
Set getDocument = doc
Else
MsgBox "URL: " & vbCrLf & "Ready state: " & .readyState & vbCrLf & "HTTP request status: " & .Status, vbInformation, "URL Not Responding"
End If
End With
End Function


This creates a JSON Collection object from the first JSON example from json.org/example.html and outputs both the values and the method used to access the values to the Immediate Window.



Example1: JSON String




"glossary":
"title": "example glossary",
"GlossDiv":
"title": "S",
"GlossList":
"GlossEntry":
"ID": "SGML",
"SortAs": "SGML",
"GlossTerm": "Standard Generalized Markup Language",
"Acronym": "SGML",
"Abbrev": "ISO 8879:1986",
"GlossDef":
"para": "A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.",
"GlossSeeAlso": ["GML", "XML"]
,
"GlossSee": "markup"





********************Example1: Output********************
colJSON!glossary!title: example glossary
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title: S
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm: Standard Generalized Markup Language
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev: ISO 8879:1986
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para: A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0): GML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1): XML Alt Syntax
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee: markup


getJSONCollection:Function



Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Object, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)
If Len(Value) = 0 Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length - 1)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add "getArray", results
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0
'Extract Array from Dictionary
If TypeName(Value) = "Dictionary" Then
If Value.Exists("getArray") Then Value = Value("getArray")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If
col.Add KeyNames(j), Value
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function


Any feedback on ways to improve the performance or valid JSON strings that it can't parse would be appreciated?




Addendum



I modify the function to use Dictionaries instead of COllections to allow access to the keys.



Corrected the handling of the Javascript IsArray. It returns true when the value is vbNullString.







share|improve this question













My goal is to create a compact function that can create a JSON Like object from JSON string. I want a function with a small footprint that I or anyone who wants to use it, can simply paste into a module and use. At 61 lines of code, I am happy with its size and portability.



Here is an image of JSON Object created from string data using a ScriptControl. Although the Locals Window displays the properties and values correctly, the object itself is extremely difficult to work with.



objJSON



This image shows an object created using getJSONCollection. Because it is made of VBA Collections and Arrays, it is very easy to work with.



colJSON



Option Explicit

Private Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Collection, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = New Collection
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)

If ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add results, "getArray"
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0

If TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If

col.Add Value, KeyNames(j)
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function

Sub TestJSONCollection()
Dim JSONExamples As Object, ExampleDoc As Object
Set ExampleDoc = getDocument("http://json.org/example.html")
Set JSONExamples = ExampleDoc.getElementsByTagName("Pre")
Example1 JSONExamples(0).innerText

End Sub

Sub Example1(JSONString As String)
Dim objJSON As Object, colJSON As Collection
Set objJSON = DecodeJSON(JSONString)
Set colJSON = getJSONCollection(JSONString)
Debug.Print "Example1: JSON String"
Debug.Print JSONString
Debug.Print String(20, "*") & "Example1: Output" & String(20, "*")

Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!title:", colJSON!glossary!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!Title
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso!getArray()(0)
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1):", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1)(1), "Alt Syntax"
Debug.Print "colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee:", colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee

End Sub

Function DecodeJSON(JSONString As String) As Object
With CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
.Language = "JScript"
Set DecodeJSON = .Eval("(" + JSONString + ")")
End With
End Function

Function getDocument(URL As String) As Object
Dim doc As Object
With CreateObject("MSXML2.XMLHTTP")
.Open "GET", URL, False
.send
If .readyState = 4 And .Status = 200 Then
Set doc = New MSHTML.HTMLDocument
doc.body.innerHTML = .responseText
Set getDocument = doc
Else
MsgBox "URL: " & vbCrLf & "Ready state: " & .readyState & vbCrLf & "HTTP request status: " & .Status, vbInformation, "URL Not Responding"
End If
End With
End Function


This creates a JSON Collection object from the first JSON example from json.org/example.html and outputs both the values and the method used to access the values to the Immediate Window.



Example1: JSON String




"glossary":
"title": "example glossary",
"GlossDiv":
"title": "S",
"GlossList":
"GlossEntry":
"ID": "SGML",
"SortAs": "SGML",
"GlossTerm": "Standard Generalized Markup Language",
"Acronym": "SGML",
"Abbrev": "ISO 8879:1986",
"GlossDef":
"para": "A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.",
"GlossSeeAlso": ["GML", "XML"]
,
"GlossSee": "markup"





********************Example1: Output********************
colJSON!glossary!title: example glossary
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!title: S
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!ID: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!SortAs: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossTerm: Standard Generalized Markup Language
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Acronym: SGML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!Abbrev: ISO 8879:1986
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!para: A meta-markup language, used to create markup languages such as DocBook.
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(0): GML
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossDef!GlossSeeAlso(1): XML Alt Syntax
colJSON!glossary!GlossDiv!GlossList!GlossEntry!GlossSee: markup


getJSONCollection:Function



Function getJSONCollection(ByVal Value As Variant, Optional ScriptEngine As Object) As Variant
Const DELIMITER As String = "||"
Dim col As Object, JSON As Object, KeyNames() As String, results() As Variant
Dim j As Long, k As Long, length As Long
Set col = CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
If ScriptEngine Is Nothing Then
Set ScriptEngine = CreateObject("MSScriptControl.ScriptControl")
ScriptEngine.Language = "JScript"
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function getKeys(jsonObj) var keys = ''; for (var n in jsonObj) keys += n + '" & DELIMITER & "' ; return keys.substring(0, keys.length-" & Len(DELIMITER) & "); "
ScriptEngine.AddCode "function isArray(jsonObj) return ( Object.prototype.toString.call( jsonObj ) === '[object Array]' ); "
End If

If TypeName(Value) = "String" Then
Set JSON = ScriptEngine.Eval("(" + Value + ")")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
Set JSON = Value
End If

KeyNames = Split(ScriptEngine.Run("getKeys", JSON), DELIMITER)
If Len(Value) = 0 Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf ScriptEngine.Run("isArray", JSON) Then
length = CallByName(JSON, "length", VbGet)
ReDim results(length - 1)

For j = 0 To length - 1
Value = CallByName(JSON, j, VbGet)
For k = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
If InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set results(j) = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(k), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
Else
If Not IsNull(Value) Then results(j) = Value
End If
Next
Next
col.Add "getArray", results
Else
For j = 0 To UBound(KeyNames)
On Error Resume Next
Set Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
If Err.Number <> 0 Then
Err.Clear
Value = CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet)
End If
On Error GoTo 0
'Extract Array from Dictionary
If TypeName(Value) = "Dictionary" Then
If Value.Exists("getArray") Then Value = Value("getArray")
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "Collection" Then
'Do Nothing
ElseIf InStr(Value, "[object Object]") Then
Set Value = getJSONCollection(CallByName(JSON, KeyNames(j), VbGet), ScriptEngine)
ElseIf TypeName(Value) = "JScriptTypeInfo" Then
'Array Handler
Set Value = getJSONCollection(Value, ScriptEngine)
End If
col.Add KeyNames(j), Value
Next

End If

Set getJSONCollection = col
End Function


Any feedback on ways to improve the performance or valid JSON strings that it can't parse would be appreciated?




Addendum



I modify the function to use Dictionaries instead of COllections to allow access to the keys.



Corrected the handling of the Javascript IsArray. It returns true when the value is vbNullString.









share|improve this question












share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Jul 2 at 2:13
























asked Jun 14 at 9:48









TinMan

51316




51316











  • Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
    – Raystafarian
    Jun 14 at 21:43










  • Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
    – TinMan
    Jun 15 at 1:04
















  • Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
    – Raystafarian
    Jun 14 at 21:43










  • Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
    – TinMan
    Jun 15 at 1:04















Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
– Raystafarian
Jun 14 at 21:43




Am I reading this right - it's heavily recursive?
– Raystafarian
Jun 14 at 21:43












Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
– TinMan
Jun 15 at 1:04




Yes, The recursion is necessary handle nested JSON objects. I actually wrote this after I started a review on your question Retrieve data from eBird API and create multi-level hierarchy of locations.
– TinMan
Jun 15 at 1:04















active

oldest

votes











Your Answer




StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
);
);
, "mathjax-editing");

StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function ()
StackExchange.using("snippets", function ()
StackExchange.snippets.init();
);
);
, "code-snippets");

StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "196"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);

else
createEditor();

);

function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: false,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);



);








 

draft saved


draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcodereview.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f196482%2ffunction-to-return-a-json-like-objects-using-vba-collections-and-arrays%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest



































active

oldest

votes













active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes










 

draft saved


draft discarded


























 


draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcodereview.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f196482%2ffunction-to-return-a-json-like-objects-using-vba-collections-and-arrays%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest













































































Popular posts from this blog

Chat program with C++ and SFML

Will my employers contract hold up in court?