Git Autoupdater

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP





.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;







up vote
1
down vote

favorite












At my office we have an internal monitoring tool we use on customer systems to monitor various vitals and notify us via Slack. Our Lead Dev and Chief Architect are very paranoid about Git, and outright refuse to put it on customer systems, however they still like the idea of using it for development.



So I created an autoupdater script for our monitoring tool that allows us to push changes to git, and have the tool auto-update from the repo without having to put git on systems.



It's written in PHP as this is the primary language in use at the office (specifically 5.3.3, although one of our devs is currently writing a technical specification for updating to 5.6), and it uses GitLab's api on our own internal gitlab host.



I've also spoofed a few details for privacy reasons, for example the config file is not called config.conf, and the service is not called tool.



<?php
//Until config can be loaded, assume _LOC is the directory of this script
$_LOC = realpath(dirname(__FILE__)).'/';

//Look for config file
echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.confn";
if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.conf'))
echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.template.confn";
if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf'))
exit('Config file does not exist and template was not found!');


//Create config from template
echo "Template exists, creating config filen";
copy($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf', $_LOC.'config/config.conf');


//Imports
require($_LOC.'lib/functions.php');
require($_LOC.'config/config.conf');
require('/etc/casper/defaults.conf');

if ($_DEBUG) echo "Starting update checkn";

if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching commitsn";
//Fetch all commits for set branch, default sorted by newest first
$commitsjson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/commits", array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
$commits = json_decode($commitsjson);
$lastcommit = $commits[0];
$lastcommit = $lastcommit->id;

if ($_DEBUG) echo "Latest commit is ".$lastcommit."n";
if ($lastcommit !== $_UPDATE_SHA)
if ($_DEBUG) echo "But current update is ".$_UPDATE_SHA."nUpdating...";
//Fetch recursive tree of all files and directories
$filejson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/tree", array('recursive' => 'true', 'ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
$fileinfo = json_decode($filejson);

//Create backup directory
$bakdate = date('Ymd');
$bakloc = $_LOC.'bak'.$bakdate.'/';
mkdir($bakloc);

$files = array();
$dirs = array();
//Format each file to url to fetch file contents and filter directories to separate array
foreach($fileinfo as $file)
if ($file->type == "blob")
$files[$file->path] = "projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/files/".$file->path;
else if ($file->type == "tree")
$dirs = $file->path;

//Create directories
foreach($dirs as $dir)
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Creating directory $dirn";
if (!file_exists($_LOC.$dir)) mkdir($_LOC.$dir);
else mkdir($bakloc.$dir);

//Fetch files
foreach($files as $path => $fileapi)
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching $pathn";
//Fetch json
$fileraw = gitlab_fetch($fileapi, array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
$fileobj = json_decode($fileraw);
//If content is set, file was successfully pulled
if (isset($fileobj->content))
//content is provided in base64, need to decode
$filecontent = base64_decode($fileobj->content);
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetched ".strlen($fileobj->content)." bytes, decoded into ".strlen($filecontent)." bytesn";
//Backup file if it already exists
if (file_exists($_LOC.$path))
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Backing up $_LOC$path to $bakloc$pathn";
copy($_LOC.$path, $bakloc.$path);

if ($_DEBUG) echo "Overwriting $_LOC$pathn";
file_put_contents($_LOC.$path, $filecontent);
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Donen";
//If message is set, an error was returned
else if (isset($fileobj->message))
//Output the error
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Failed to download $path with response ".$fileobj->message."n";



//Update the commit hash
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Updating commit hashn";
file_put_contents($_LOC.'config/update-hash', $lastcommit);
if ($_DEBUG) echo "Restarting tool...n";
//Log restart in slack, and restart service
slack_pretty_log('Tool Updated', "Tool $_VERSION has updated! Restarting...", 'good');
$output = shell_exec('sudo /etc/init.d/tool restart 2>&1');
if ($_DEBUG) echo $output;
//End
else
if ($_DEBUG) echo "No new updatesn";



Functions such as slack_pretty_log and gitlab_fetch are defined externally and use the respective APIs, and any variables beginning with underscores (such as $_DEBUG and $_GIT_BRANCH) are defined in the config file.



I'm mainly interested in feedback on the flow of the logic itself, as well as naming conventions (which I admittedly didn't do a great job of adhering to) and comments.



This is a standalone script designed to run once per day on a cronjob, which is why it has a lot of logic outside of any functions or classes.







share|improve this question



























    up vote
    1
    down vote

    favorite












    At my office we have an internal monitoring tool we use on customer systems to monitor various vitals and notify us via Slack. Our Lead Dev and Chief Architect are very paranoid about Git, and outright refuse to put it on customer systems, however they still like the idea of using it for development.



    So I created an autoupdater script for our monitoring tool that allows us to push changes to git, and have the tool auto-update from the repo without having to put git on systems.



    It's written in PHP as this is the primary language in use at the office (specifically 5.3.3, although one of our devs is currently writing a technical specification for updating to 5.6), and it uses GitLab's api on our own internal gitlab host.



    I've also spoofed a few details for privacy reasons, for example the config file is not called config.conf, and the service is not called tool.



    <?php
    //Until config can be loaded, assume _LOC is the directory of this script
    $_LOC = realpath(dirname(__FILE__)).'/';

    //Look for config file
    echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.confn";
    if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.conf'))
    echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.template.confn";
    if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf'))
    exit('Config file does not exist and template was not found!');


    //Create config from template
    echo "Template exists, creating config filen";
    copy($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf', $_LOC.'config/config.conf');


    //Imports
    require($_LOC.'lib/functions.php');
    require($_LOC.'config/config.conf');
    require('/etc/casper/defaults.conf');

    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Starting update checkn";

    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching commitsn";
    //Fetch all commits for set branch, default sorted by newest first
    $commitsjson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/commits", array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
    $commits = json_decode($commitsjson);
    $lastcommit = $commits[0];
    $lastcommit = $lastcommit->id;

    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Latest commit is ".$lastcommit."n";
    if ($lastcommit !== $_UPDATE_SHA)
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "But current update is ".$_UPDATE_SHA."nUpdating...";
    //Fetch recursive tree of all files and directories
    $filejson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/tree", array('recursive' => 'true', 'ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
    $fileinfo = json_decode($filejson);

    //Create backup directory
    $bakdate = date('Ymd');
    $bakloc = $_LOC.'bak'.$bakdate.'/';
    mkdir($bakloc);

    $files = array();
    $dirs = array();
    //Format each file to url to fetch file contents and filter directories to separate array
    foreach($fileinfo as $file)
    if ($file->type == "blob")
    $files[$file->path] = "projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/files/".$file->path;
    else if ($file->type == "tree")
    $dirs = $file->path;

    //Create directories
    foreach($dirs as $dir)
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Creating directory $dirn";
    if (!file_exists($_LOC.$dir)) mkdir($_LOC.$dir);
    else mkdir($bakloc.$dir);

    //Fetch files
    foreach($files as $path => $fileapi)
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching $pathn";
    //Fetch json
    $fileraw = gitlab_fetch($fileapi, array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
    $fileobj = json_decode($fileraw);
    //If content is set, file was successfully pulled
    if (isset($fileobj->content))
    //content is provided in base64, need to decode
    $filecontent = base64_decode($fileobj->content);
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetched ".strlen($fileobj->content)." bytes, decoded into ".strlen($filecontent)." bytesn";
    //Backup file if it already exists
    if (file_exists($_LOC.$path))
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Backing up $_LOC$path to $bakloc$pathn";
    copy($_LOC.$path, $bakloc.$path);

    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Overwriting $_LOC$pathn";
    file_put_contents($_LOC.$path, $filecontent);
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Donen";
    //If message is set, an error was returned
    else if (isset($fileobj->message))
    //Output the error
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Failed to download $path with response ".$fileobj->message."n";



    //Update the commit hash
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Updating commit hashn";
    file_put_contents($_LOC.'config/update-hash', $lastcommit);
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "Restarting tool...n";
    //Log restart in slack, and restart service
    slack_pretty_log('Tool Updated', "Tool $_VERSION has updated! Restarting...", 'good');
    $output = shell_exec('sudo /etc/init.d/tool restart 2>&1');
    if ($_DEBUG) echo $output;
    //End
    else
    if ($_DEBUG) echo "No new updatesn";



    Functions such as slack_pretty_log and gitlab_fetch are defined externally and use the respective APIs, and any variables beginning with underscores (such as $_DEBUG and $_GIT_BRANCH) are defined in the config file.



    I'm mainly interested in feedback on the flow of the logic itself, as well as naming conventions (which I admittedly didn't do a great job of adhering to) and comments.



    This is a standalone script designed to run once per day on a cronjob, which is why it has a lot of logic outside of any functions or classes.







    share|improve this question























      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite









      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite











      At my office we have an internal monitoring tool we use on customer systems to monitor various vitals and notify us via Slack. Our Lead Dev and Chief Architect are very paranoid about Git, and outright refuse to put it on customer systems, however they still like the idea of using it for development.



      So I created an autoupdater script for our monitoring tool that allows us to push changes to git, and have the tool auto-update from the repo without having to put git on systems.



      It's written in PHP as this is the primary language in use at the office (specifically 5.3.3, although one of our devs is currently writing a technical specification for updating to 5.6), and it uses GitLab's api on our own internal gitlab host.



      I've also spoofed a few details for privacy reasons, for example the config file is not called config.conf, and the service is not called tool.



      <?php
      //Until config can be loaded, assume _LOC is the directory of this script
      $_LOC = realpath(dirname(__FILE__)).'/';

      //Look for config file
      echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.confn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.conf'))
      echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.template.confn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf'))
      exit('Config file does not exist and template was not found!');


      //Create config from template
      echo "Template exists, creating config filen";
      copy($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf', $_LOC.'config/config.conf');


      //Imports
      require($_LOC.'lib/functions.php');
      require($_LOC.'config/config.conf');
      require('/etc/casper/defaults.conf');

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Starting update checkn";

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching commitsn";
      //Fetch all commits for set branch, default sorted by newest first
      $commitsjson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/commits", array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $commits = json_decode($commitsjson);
      $lastcommit = $commits[0];
      $lastcommit = $lastcommit->id;

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Latest commit is ".$lastcommit."n";
      if ($lastcommit !== $_UPDATE_SHA)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "But current update is ".$_UPDATE_SHA."nUpdating...";
      //Fetch recursive tree of all files and directories
      $filejson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/tree", array('recursive' => 'true', 'ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $fileinfo = json_decode($filejson);

      //Create backup directory
      $bakdate = date('Ymd');
      $bakloc = $_LOC.'bak'.$bakdate.'/';
      mkdir($bakloc);

      $files = array();
      $dirs = array();
      //Format each file to url to fetch file contents and filter directories to separate array
      foreach($fileinfo as $file)
      if ($file->type == "blob")
      $files[$file->path] = "projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/files/".$file->path;
      else if ($file->type == "tree")
      $dirs = $file->path;

      //Create directories
      foreach($dirs as $dir)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Creating directory $dirn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.$dir)) mkdir($_LOC.$dir);
      else mkdir($bakloc.$dir);

      //Fetch files
      foreach($files as $path => $fileapi)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching $pathn";
      //Fetch json
      $fileraw = gitlab_fetch($fileapi, array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $fileobj = json_decode($fileraw);
      //If content is set, file was successfully pulled
      if (isset($fileobj->content))
      //content is provided in base64, need to decode
      $filecontent = base64_decode($fileobj->content);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetched ".strlen($fileobj->content)." bytes, decoded into ".strlen($filecontent)." bytesn";
      //Backup file if it already exists
      if (file_exists($_LOC.$path))
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Backing up $_LOC$path to $bakloc$pathn";
      copy($_LOC.$path, $bakloc.$path);

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Overwriting $_LOC$pathn";
      file_put_contents($_LOC.$path, $filecontent);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Donen";
      //If message is set, an error was returned
      else if (isset($fileobj->message))
      //Output the error
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Failed to download $path with response ".$fileobj->message."n";



      //Update the commit hash
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Updating commit hashn";
      file_put_contents($_LOC.'config/update-hash', $lastcommit);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Restarting tool...n";
      //Log restart in slack, and restart service
      slack_pretty_log('Tool Updated', "Tool $_VERSION has updated! Restarting...", 'good');
      $output = shell_exec('sudo /etc/init.d/tool restart 2>&1');
      if ($_DEBUG) echo $output;
      //End
      else
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "No new updatesn";



      Functions such as slack_pretty_log and gitlab_fetch are defined externally and use the respective APIs, and any variables beginning with underscores (such as $_DEBUG and $_GIT_BRANCH) are defined in the config file.



      I'm mainly interested in feedback on the flow of the logic itself, as well as naming conventions (which I admittedly didn't do a great job of adhering to) and comments.



      This is a standalone script designed to run once per day on a cronjob, which is why it has a lot of logic outside of any functions or classes.







      share|improve this question













      At my office we have an internal monitoring tool we use on customer systems to monitor various vitals and notify us via Slack. Our Lead Dev and Chief Architect are very paranoid about Git, and outright refuse to put it on customer systems, however they still like the idea of using it for development.



      So I created an autoupdater script for our monitoring tool that allows us to push changes to git, and have the tool auto-update from the repo without having to put git on systems.



      It's written in PHP as this is the primary language in use at the office (specifically 5.3.3, although one of our devs is currently writing a technical specification for updating to 5.6), and it uses GitLab's api on our own internal gitlab host.



      I've also spoofed a few details for privacy reasons, for example the config file is not called config.conf, and the service is not called tool.



      <?php
      //Until config can be loaded, assume _LOC is the directory of this script
      $_LOC = realpath(dirname(__FILE__)).'/';

      //Look for config file
      echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.confn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.conf'))
      echo "Searching for ".$_LOC."config/config.template.confn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf'))
      exit('Config file does not exist and template was not found!');


      //Create config from template
      echo "Template exists, creating config filen";
      copy($_LOC.'config/config.template.conf', $_LOC.'config/config.conf');


      //Imports
      require($_LOC.'lib/functions.php');
      require($_LOC.'config/config.conf');
      require('/etc/casper/defaults.conf');

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Starting update checkn";

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching commitsn";
      //Fetch all commits for set branch, default sorted by newest first
      $commitsjson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/commits", array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $commits = json_decode($commitsjson);
      $lastcommit = $commits[0];
      $lastcommit = $lastcommit->id;

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Latest commit is ".$lastcommit."n";
      if ($lastcommit !== $_UPDATE_SHA)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "But current update is ".$_UPDATE_SHA."nUpdating...";
      //Fetch recursive tree of all files and directories
      $filejson = gitlab_fetch("projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/tree", array('recursive' => 'true', 'ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $fileinfo = json_decode($filejson);

      //Create backup directory
      $bakdate = date('Ymd');
      $bakloc = $_LOC.'bak'.$bakdate.'/';
      mkdir($bakloc);

      $files = array();
      $dirs = array();
      //Format each file to url to fetch file contents and filter directories to separate array
      foreach($fileinfo as $file)
      if ($file->type == "blob")
      $files[$file->path] = "projects/$_GIT_ID/repository/files/".$file->path;
      else if ($file->type == "tree")
      $dirs = $file->path;

      //Create directories
      foreach($dirs as $dir)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Creating directory $dirn";
      if (!file_exists($_LOC.$dir)) mkdir($_LOC.$dir);
      else mkdir($bakloc.$dir);

      //Fetch files
      foreach($files as $path => $fileapi)
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetching $pathn";
      //Fetch json
      $fileraw = gitlab_fetch($fileapi, array('ref' => $_GIT_BRANCH));
      $fileobj = json_decode($fileraw);
      //If content is set, file was successfully pulled
      if (isset($fileobj->content))
      //content is provided in base64, need to decode
      $filecontent = base64_decode($fileobj->content);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Fetched ".strlen($fileobj->content)." bytes, decoded into ".strlen($filecontent)." bytesn";
      //Backup file if it already exists
      if (file_exists($_LOC.$path))
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Backing up $_LOC$path to $bakloc$pathn";
      copy($_LOC.$path, $bakloc.$path);

      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Overwriting $_LOC$pathn";
      file_put_contents($_LOC.$path, $filecontent);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Donen";
      //If message is set, an error was returned
      else if (isset($fileobj->message))
      //Output the error
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Failed to download $path with response ".$fileobj->message."n";



      //Update the commit hash
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Updating commit hashn";
      file_put_contents($_LOC.'config/update-hash', $lastcommit);
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "Restarting tool...n";
      //Log restart in slack, and restart service
      slack_pretty_log('Tool Updated', "Tool $_VERSION has updated! Restarting...", 'good');
      $output = shell_exec('sudo /etc/init.d/tool restart 2>&1');
      if ($_DEBUG) echo $output;
      //End
      else
      if ($_DEBUG) echo "No new updatesn";



      Functions such as slack_pretty_log and gitlab_fetch are defined externally and use the respective APIs, and any variables beginning with underscores (such as $_DEBUG and $_GIT_BRANCH) are defined in the config file.



      I'm mainly interested in feedback on the flow of the logic itself, as well as naming conventions (which I admittedly didn't do a great job of adhering to) and comments.



      This is a standalone script designed to run once per day on a cronjob, which is why it has a lot of logic outside of any functions or classes.









      share|improve this question












      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited Feb 7 at 17:26









      200_success

      123k14143401




      123k14143401









      asked Feb 7 at 16:15









      Skidsdev

      13613




      13613




















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes

















          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Why have you repeated if ($_DEBUG) echo a zillion times? That is begging to be embedded in a debug() function.



          Every time you have a comment with a chunk of logic underneath it, that should be a method (named what the comment says).






          share|improve this answer





















          • I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 10:17










          • What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:08











          • My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 17:33










          • Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:46










          • Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 21:12










          Your Answer




          StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
          return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
          StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
          StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
          );
          );
          , "mathjax-editing");

          StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function ()
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function ()
          StackExchange.snippets.init();
          );
          );
          , "code-snippets");

          StackExchange.ready(function()
          var channelOptions =
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "196"
          ;
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
          createEditor();
          );

          else
          createEditor();

          );

          function createEditor()
          StackExchange.prepareEditor(
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          convertImagesToLinks: false,
          noModals: false,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: null,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          );



          );








           

          draft saved


          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcodereview.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f187020%2fgit-autoupdater%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest






























          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes








          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes








          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Why have you repeated if ($_DEBUG) echo a zillion times? That is begging to be embedded in a debug() function.



          Every time you have a comment with a chunk of logic underneath it, that should be a method (named what the comment says).






          share|improve this answer





















          • I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 10:17










          • What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:08











          • My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 17:33










          • Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:46










          • Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 21:12














          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Why have you repeated if ($_DEBUG) echo a zillion times? That is begging to be embedded in a debug() function.



          Every time you have a comment with a chunk of logic underneath it, that should be a method (named what the comment says).






          share|improve this answer





















          • I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 10:17










          • What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:08











          • My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 17:33










          • Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:46










          • Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 21:12












          up vote
          1
          down vote










          up vote
          1
          down vote









          Why have you repeated if ($_DEBUG) echo a zillion times? That is begging to be embedded in a debug() function.



          Every time you have a comment with a chunk of logic underneath it, that should be a method (named what the comment says).






          share|improve this answer













          Why have you repeated if ($_DEBUG) echo a zillion times? That is begging to be embedded in a debug() function.



          Every time you have a comment with a chunk of logic underneath it, that should be a method (named what the comment says).







          share|improve this answer













          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer











          answered Feb 7 at 17:45









          Bryan Boettcher

          1234




          1234











          • I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 10:17










          • What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:08











          • My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 17:33










          • Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:46










          • Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 21:12
















          • I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 10:17










          • What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:08











          • My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 17:33










          • Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
            – Bryan Boettcher
            Feb 8 at 17:46










          • Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
            – Skidsdev
            Feb 8 at 21:12















          I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 10:17




          I agree with your comment regarding the debug echo repetition, and I've added a debug function for that now, however given the nature of the script, and the nature of function calls in PHP, it seems pointless and even counter productive to needlessly split the entire script up into functions that will only be run once
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 10:17












          What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
          – Bryan Boettcher
          Feb 8 at 17:08





          What, pray tell, is it about functions in PHP that makes introducing them a bad idea? The introduction is for readability, not performance.
          – Bryan Boettcher
          Feb 8 at 17:08













          My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 17:33




          My issue, aside from the performance issues, is that it leads to a code flow like this, which in my opinion worsens readability, rather than improves it
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 17:33












          Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
          – Bryan Boettcher
          Feb 8 at 17:46




          Ah, yes, the performance issues from function overhead on a once-a-day script :) You're also stating, with a straight face, that a nested method call is LESS readable than 20 lines of code nested inside the same if statement?
          – Bryan Boettcher
          Feb 8 at 17:46












          Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 21:12




          Yes I am, because if you just have a series of function calls within an if statement, you essentially have magic black boxes as far as readability is concerned, and you have to scroll down or open a different file to look at the function declarations, which breaks the flow completely
          – Skidsdev
          Feb 8 at 21:12












           

          draft saved


          draft discarded


























           


          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcodereview.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f187020%2fgit-autoupdater%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest













































































          Popular posts from this blog

          Chat program with C++ and SFML

          Function to Return a JSON Like Objects Using VBA Collections and Arrays

          Will my employers contract hold up in court?